Travel Agent vs. Costco Travel: Which is Right for Your Next Vacation?

Planning your dream vacation? You might be wondering whether to work with a professional travel advisor or to book your trip through Costco Travel.

While both options can save you time and money, the experience and results they offer can be vastly different. At New Dawn Vacations, I believe in empowering travelers with the knowledge they need to make informed decisions. Here's a breakdown of the similarities and differences so you can choose the travel planning method that fits your needs.

What They Have in Common:

1. Package Deals & Perks

Both travel advisors and Costco Travel offer package deals that combine flights, accommodations, and extras like airport transfers or onboard cruise credits. Either way, you may receive bonuses that wouldn’t be available if booking on your own.

2. Time Savings

Whether you're using Costco Travel’s platform or working with a dedicated advisor, you save countless hours otherwise spent comparing websites, reading reviews, and managing logistics.

3. Access to Exclusive Rates

Costco Travel benefits from bulk-buying power, while travel advisors like us at New Dawn Vacations leverage our network of luxury partners to secure exclusive perks, upgrades, and better-than-public rates.

Key Differences Between a Travel Advisor and Costco Travel:

1. Personalization vs. One-Size-Fits-All

Travel Advisor: We take the time to get to know your travel style, preferences, and goals—creating customized itineraries just for you. Whether you're planning a romantic LGBTQ+ honeymoon or an adventurous escape to New Zealand, your trip is uniquely yours.

Costco Travel: Offers set packages with limited room for personalization. You pick from a menu of pre-designed options, and special requests may not always be accommodated.

2. Human Connection

Travel Advisor: You’ll work with the same dedicated professional throughout the planning process. We learn your preferences over time and become your go-to for future trips.

Costco Travel: Most bookings are made online. If you need support, you'll speak to whoever is available in the call center, without a consistent point of contact.

3. Support During Travel

Travel Advisor: If a flight is canceled or your room isn't what was promised, we step in and handle it—often before you even know there’s an issue.

Costco Travel: You'll need to call customer service, which may be limited to business hours and slower to resolve complex issues.

4. Trip Complexity

Travel Advisor: Ideal for multi-stop itineraries, destination weddings, luxury honeymoons, or immersive cultural experiences. At New Dawn Vacations, we specialize in high-touch planning for complex travel needs.

Costco Travel: Best for simple vacations such as cruises, all-inclusive stays, or quick getaways.

5. Cost Structure

Travel Advisor: Some charge a planning fee (I do) for custom travel design—but with that comes VIP perks, upgrades, and a trip tailored to you. Think of it as an investment in peace of mind.

Costco Travel: Requires a Costco membership. There are no planning fees, but personalization and hands-on service are limited.

Which One Is Right for You?

Choose a travel advisor if you value expert guidance, personalized experiences, and having an advocate throughout your journey.
Choose Costco Travel if you prefer self-service, want a simple vacation package, and already have a membership.

Get Started Now